Is CCA 202352018 the Death of Irrevocable Trust Decantings?
For years, practitioners have freely used irrevocable trust decantings as a means to make various changes to irrevocable trusts without concern of giving rise to gift tax consequences. However, the Internal Revenue Service’s (“IRS”) Chief Counsel Advice Memorandum (CCA 202352018) (the “CCA”) may be the death to irrevocable trust decantings as we know them.
The term “irrevocable trust” is somewhat of a misnomer—there are mechanisms by which irrevocable trusts can be modified in certain respects. Generally, irrevocable trusts can be modified in one of two ways depending on applicable state law: (i) some states, such as New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and Connecticut, permit an irrevocable trust to be modified with the consent of the beneficiaries and the trustee (some states also require the consent of the settlor if he or she is then living), which is typically referred to as a “non-judicial modification;” and (ii) some states, such as New York, Delaware, and Florida, permit an irrevocable trust to be modified by a decanting, which is a process by which an authorized trustee exercises his or her independent discretion to pay over the property of the trust to a new trust that has different terms.
For years, practitioners have been concerned that using a non-judicial modification to make certain changes with the consent of the beneficiaries (such as removing a beneficiary, shifting beneficial interests, or diluting a beneficiary’s interest), may be deemed to be a taxable gift by the beneficiaries. However, this concern was not present with respect to decantings since a decanting is effectuated by the independent act of an authorized trustee, who does not have a beneficial interest in the trust, without the consent of the beneficiaries. That was, until the CCA.
To read the full post, please visit our Future Wealth Navigator blog.