The Florida Division of Administrative Hearings (the “DOAH”) recently struck down a revision to a regulation issued by the Florida Department of Revenue (the “Department”). Amusement Machine Owners’ Ass’n of Florida v. Fla. Dep’t of Rev., Case No. 26-4757RX (Fla. Div. Admin. Hearings Oct. 27, 2026). The revised rule modified the forms that amusement machine operators used to register for sales tax. The DOAH found the revision was an invalid exercise of delegated legislative authority.
The DOAH’s decision exemplifies the principle that the Department’s rulemaking power exists to administer Florida’s taxes, not to enforce laws entrusted to other agencies. It matters beyond the amusement machine industry as an illustrative application of Florida’s Administrative Procedure Act (“APA”) and its core principle that every rule be authorized by a specific grant of authority. It also shows how even seemingly clerical matters, such as the text of an agency form, can constitute a challengeable rule.
The Revision: Florida Statutes section 212.05(1)(h) imposes a sales tax on charges for the use of any “coin-operated amusement machine,” defined as any machine operated by coin, token, or similar device “for the purposes of entertainment or amusement,” including pinball machines, arcade games, billiard tables, “and all other similar amusement devices.” Operators must complete certain forms to obtain an Amusement Machine Certificate for each location, which the Department uses to identify taxable machines.
Effective September 3, 2026, the Department amended Rule 12A-1.097(8)(a)–(d) to add language to the attestations on the forms completed by the operators (the “Revision”). Applicants now had to certify, under penalty of perjury, that each machine is a “game of skill” and not a slot-type machine, a game of chance, video poker, or a federal gambling device. The language appears to be borrowed from the Family Amusement Games Act, section 546.10, which the Department does not administer.
The Challenge: The Amusement Machine Owners’ Association challenged the Revision as an invalid exercise of delegated legislative authority. The Department responded, arguing that the rule was valid because it addressed the general subject matter of the laws purportedly authorizing it.
The DOAH confirmed that the revised forms are themselves a “rule,” because the APA defines a rule to include any form that solicits information not specifically required by statute or an existing rule.
The Decision: The DOAH began its analysis with Florida Statutes Section 120.52(8), which states that a rule constitutes an invalid exercise of delegated legislative authority when “the agency has exceeded its grant of rulemaking authority…. the rule enlarges, modifies or contravenes the specific provisions of law implemented… [or] the rule is arbitrary and capricious.”
The DOAH also emphasized the “flush left” paragraph of section 120.52(8), which requires a rule to actually implement the specific powers granted by the enabling statute. It is insufficient that the rule be only “reasonably related” to the enabling statute or fall within the agency’s general class of powers.
The DOAH examined each of the statutes purportedly authorizing the rule and found that none authorized requiring taxpayers to comply with laws enforced by other agencies:
- Section 212.05(1)(h)6. authorizes the adoption of rules necessary to “administer” the tax on coin-operated machines. However, redefining which machines are lawful under the gambling statutes, the DOAH wrote, “does not administer a tax.”
- Section 212.12(1)(b)2. authorizes rules requesting from taxpayers information necessary to properly collect, review, compile, report, and enforce the taxes levied, including sales data, tax collected or due, refunds, etc. It does not, however, include information regarding the nature of coin-operated amusement machines.
- Section 212.18(3)(a) directs dealers, in general, to register for sales tax with the Department, and likewise says nothing about the nature or operation of the machines.
In its review, the DOAH compared the case to State, Bd. of Trustees of the Internal Improvement Trust Fund v. Day Cruise Ass’n, Inc., which struck a proposed rule barring “cruises to nowhere” gambling ships from mooring on certain state-owned land because the agency, whose purpose was to hold title to and manage state-owned lands, had no specific power to regulate gambling.
The DOAH found that the Revision also impermissibly modified the statutory definition of “coin-operated amusement machine” under section 212.02(24) by requiring that operators certify that machines meet the narrower definition of an “amusement game or machine” (i.e., games of skill only) provided under the Family Amusement Games Act.
The Department admitted that the Revision “largely address[es]” Florida’s gambling laws, but argued that it should not be required to register machines for sales tax that might be unlawful under those laws. In the Department’s view, borrowing the gambling laws’ definition was justified. However, the DOAH concluded, had the legislature wanted to exclude from tax the receipts from certain machines (e.g., illegal ones), it could have done so. Its failure to do so “suggests that the Legislature intended [to] tax receipts from all coin-operated amusement machines.” (emphasis preserved.)
This update is one in a series of updates written for the November 2026 edition of The BR State + Local Tax Spotlight.
© 2026 Blank Rome LLP. All rights reserved. Please contact Blank Rome for permission to reprint. Notice: The purpose of this update is to identify select developments that may be of interest to readers. The information contained herein is abridged and summarized from various sources, the accuracy and completeness of which cannot be assured. This update should not be construed as legal advice or opinion, and is not a substitute for the advice of counsel.
