When seeking relief from an action taken by a state or local taxing authority, it is critical to follow the appeal procedure provided for in the law. No matter how right a taxpayer may be on the merits of its appeal, if the proper appeal procedure is not followed, a court is likely to find that it lacks jurisdiction to grant the relief that the taxpayer is seeking in the case. A recent decision by an intermediate appellate court in Kentucky demonstrates this point. In Huston v. Commonwealth of Kentucky, No. 2025-CA-1034-MR (Ky. Ct. App. Oct. 30, 2026), the Kentucky Court of Appeals affirmed the dismissal on procedural grounds of lawsuits brought by a retailer and individuals seeking sales tax refunds. The Court found that the parties had not followed the procedure prescribed by law for seeking refunds for sales tax paid and had failed to exhaust their administrative remedies before bringing their claims to court. This case is a reminder to taxpayers that correctly following tax appeal procedures is just as important to winning a tax case as being correct on the substantive tax question.

The case here arose from unusual facts. The Kentucky General Assembly enacted legislation exempting “currency and bullion” from sales tax, and the Governor subsequently issued a line-item veto of the provision. The General Assembly did not vote to override the Governor’s veto but instead obtained an opinion from the Attorney General designating the veto as invalid. Based on the Attorney General’s opinion, the Kentucky House ruled that the Governor’s veto was invalid and delivered the legislation to the Secretary of State, and the Kentucky statutes were amended to reflect the new exemption. However, at the direction of the Governor, the Kentucky Department of Revenue continued to require the collection of sales tax on sales of currency and bullion. In response, the General Assembly passed new legislation allowing any person who paid sales tax on currency or bullion after the effective date of the exemption to bring a lawsuit seeking a refund of those paid taxes. The Governor eventually acquiesced, and the Department of Revenue issued guidance on its website for taxpayers to seek refunds for sales tax paid on currency and bullion currency after the effective date of the exemption.

Three individuals brought lawsuits in Kentucky Circuit Court seeking refunds of sales tax that they paid on their purchase of silver bullion from a retailer after the effective date of the exemption. They did not attempt to obtain a refund directly from the Department of Revenue. Money Metals, an Idaho limited liability company and one of the largest online retailers of gold and silver bullion in the U.S., also filed a lawsuit on its own behalf and on behalf of its Kentucky customers from whom it had collected and remitted sales tax after the effective date of the exemption. Like the individuals, Money Metals did not seek to obtain a refund directly from the Department of Revenue before bringing its lawsuit.

With respect to Money Metals, the Court of Appeals affirmed the lower court’s decision dismissing the case for lack of jurisdiction due to Money Metals’ failure to exhaust its administrative remedies. Finding Money Metals was neither challenging the constitutionality of the relevant tax provisions nor arguing that seeking a refund directly from the Department of Revenue would be futile, the Court of Appeals agreed that the lower court “had no jurisdiction to hear the case.” The Court explained that it “will not take jurisdiction to render a declaratory judgment. . . where the purpose is to affect proceedings which may be taken or pending before a public board which is vested with full power to act in the premises.” Here, the Department of Revenue was such a public board vested with full power to act on the refund claims. 

The individuals, however, argued that their seeking a refund from the Department of Revenue would be futile because the relevant statute only permitted a refund to be issued to the person who paid the tax to the state, which in this case would have been the retailer who sold the silver bullion to the individuals. While the court agreed that it would be futile for the individuals to seek a refund, it nonetheless affirmed the dismissal of their case as well, explaining “[t]he appropriate and statutorily permissible means by which [the individuals] may obtain a tax refund is to request a refund from. . . the retailer permitted to request a refund on their behalf and obligated to then return those monies to their customers.”    


This update is one in a series of updates written for the November 2026 edition of The BR State + Local Tax Spotlight.


© 2026 Blank Rome LLP. All rights reserved. Please contact Blank Rome for permission to reprint. Notice: The purpose of this update is to identify select developments that may be of interest to readers. The information contained herein is abridged and summarized from various sources, the accuracy and completeness of which cannot be assured. This update should not be construed as legal advice or opinion, and is not a substitute for the advice of counsel.