The California Franchise Tax Board (“FTB”) failed in its attempt to re-litigate an issue that it lost in 2010, which is the use of tax credits against the Alternative Minimum Tax (“AMT”). In a decision released recently by the Office of Tax Appeals (“OTA”), the FTB lost its attempt to defend its adjustment to eliminate use of the research credit against the AMT. In re Medivation, Inc., 2026-OTA-532P (Office of Tax App. Jan. 27, 2026) (Pending Precedential).
In the year at issue, 2015, Medivation, Inc. (“Medivation”) was a corporation that was headquartered in California and filed a world-wide combined report that included subsidiary Medivation Prostate Therapeutics, Inc. (“MPT”). MPT computed its tentative minimum tax and then subtracted the minimum tax, resulting in its computed AMT amount. It then fully offset the AMT amount by research credits to which it was entitled, resulting in Medivation reporting zero AMT. The FTB audited and made adjustments to eliminate the offset of AMT by research credits.
It was undisputed on appeal that Medivation correctly calculated its AMT and that the world-wide group and MPT properly computed the research credits and were able to so claim the research credits under R&TC Section 23609. The only dispute was whether MPT correctly claimed an offset of the AMT liability with the research credits.
The Board of Equalization ("BOE") (a tribunal that existed prior to the OTA’s operation) previously held, in a precedential decision, that a taxpayer could use its properly earned enterprise zone hiring credits and manufacturer’s investment credits to offset its corporate AMT liability. NASSCO Holdings, Inc. (2010-SBE-001) 2010 WL 5626976 (2010). The FTB attempted to have the OTA overturn the BOE’s NASSCO decision and, short of overturning NASSCO outright, to distinguish NASSCO as inapplicable to research credits such that Medivation could not use its subsidiary’s research credits to offset AMT liability. The OTA disagreed with the FTB’s positions, upheld NASSCO, declined to distinguish NASSCO as applying only to enterprise zone hiring credits and manufacturer’s investment credits, and allowed Medivation to offset AMT with the research credits.
The FTB claimed that the term “tax” as defined in the statutes does not include the AMT. The FTB asserted that the term “tax” was unambiguous in R&TC 23036(d) (the paragraph that addresses research credits). The OTA found that the term “tax” is defined to include the corporation income tax and the alternative minimum tax under R&TC 23036(a) & (b), but the BOE in NASSCO had found that definition ambiguous. Slip Op. at 4-6. The OTA also found that the NASSCO decision addressed and rejected the FTB’s ambiguity argument. The FTB requested that the OTA overturn NASSCO as purportedly “wrongly decided and … ‘bad law.’” Slip Op. at 6. The OTA concluded that a “precedential opinion of the [BOE] that was adopted prior to January 1, 2018 [such as NASSCO], may be cited as precedential authority to the OTA unless the OTA removes, in whole or in part, the precedential status of that opinion ….” Slip Op. at 6 (citing and quoting 18 CCR 30504). The OTA analyzed whether the BOE’s decision in NASSCO was still good law, noted that the legislature amended the relevant statute section eight times after NASSCO was decided and did not modify the law to change the future outcome of the issue of credits used against the AMT. Thus, the OTA held that NASSCO is still good law.
Next, the FTB asserted that NASSCO is distinguishable because NASSCO did not address use of the research credits against the AMT and for Medivation, the issue is the AMT offset by research credits. The OTA observed that the FTB did not explain why NASSCO is distinguishable and instead reiterated its initial argument that NASSCO should be overturned. Inasmuch as the FTB raised no compelling argument to distinguish NASSCO, the OTA declined to now distinguish NASSCO and, as a result, allowed Medivation to use the research credits against the AMT.
The Takeaways: It is important, when briefing arguments, to ensure that each argument is clear, concise, and distinguishable from the other argument points. Further, even when you correctly follow the statute and the caselaw, new administrations will occasionally attempt to re-litigate old issues when they disagree with prior case law, particularly when they have been unsuccessful pressing for a law change in the legislature. Here, the OTA did the right thing, and this is a prime example of why legislatures should allow attorneys’ fees against states at 100% of the amount of the fees expended.
This update is one in a series of updates written for the November 2026 edition of The BR State + Local Tax Spotlight.
© 2026 Blank Rome LLP. All rights reserved. Please contact Blank Rome for permission to reprint. Notice: The purpose of this update is to identify select developments that may be of interest to readers. The information contained herein is abridged and summarized from various sources, the accuracy and completeness of which cannot be assured. This update should not be construed as legal advice or opinion, and is not a substitute for the advice of counsel.
